3 Best Eyebrow Pencils for You (2020)

 May 25, 2020

By  BC Editorial Team

Are you looking to revamp your eyebrow routine? Whether you’ve been using the same eyebrow product for years or you’ve never put any product on your brows, changing the game every once in a while is a great way to refresh your look and keep your beauty routine exciting. Eyebrow pencils are just one of the many ways to achieve the best, boldest, and most beautiful brows.

We have found the best three eyebrow pencils of the year by searching through product reviews, video tutorials, and formula comparisons. Whether you like your brows bold or simple, there is a product in this list that meets your requirements. Here are the top three eyebrow pencils of 2020:

Best Eyebrow Pencil Center

Jane Iredale Pencil
  • Smooth finish
  • Vitamin enriched
  • Range of colors to select from
jane iredale Retractable Brow Pencil
  • No sharpening required
  • Brush wand included
  • Range of colors
Pretty Vulgar - Defined Brilliance Eyebrow Pencil
  • No sharpening required
  • Blendable and smooth
  • Wand included

Each of these products has its own unique qualities to offer. After reading more in detail about each eyebrow pencil you are sure to find your perfect match.

1. Jane Iredale Pencil

jane iredale Eye Pencil, Taupe

This eyebrow pencil is so smooth, it can double as an eyeliner pencil. With multiple natural shades to choose from and skin-supporting vitamins coating your brows along with the color, your skin will thank you for choosing to combine health and beauty into one product selection. This pencil doesn’t dull quickly and gets many uses before needing to be sharpened so you’ll never feel it catch or drag your skin.

  • Specs
  • Pros
  • Video

  • 0.04 ounce
  • Wide shade range

  • Smooth application
  • Easy to apply
  • Stays on all day
  • Doubles as eyeliner
  • Cruelty free formula
  • Vitamin enriched formula
  • Doubles as lip liner

YouTube video

Check Price on Amazon

2.  jane iredale Retractable Brow Pencil

jane iredale Retractable Brow Pencil, Ash Blonde, 0.09 oz.

This eyebrow pencil requires no sharpening and has a brush on the other end to help evenly distribute the product. Jane Iredale offers all-natural, non-toxic, and cruelty-free formulas in all of the makeup they produce, so you can rest assured this product will be safe for your skin and the environment. With the wide range of colors offered for this eyebrow pencil, you are guaranteed to find your perfect match.

  • Specs
  • Pros
  • Video

  • 0.003 ounce
  • Wide shade range

  • Natural finish
  • Lasts throughout the day
  • Easy to use

YouTube video

Check Price on Amazon

3. Pretty Vulgar – Defined Brilliance Eyebrow Pencil

Pretty Vulgar - Defined Brilliance Eyebrow Pencil, Clean & Cruelty-Free, Quick Wit (Medium Brown)

This eyebrow pencil requires no sharpening and has a brush on the other end to help evenly distribute the product. With the wide range of colors offered for this eyebrow pencil, you are guaranteed to find your perfect match. This eyebrow pencil applies smoothly, lasts all day, and has a fantastic finish.

  • Specs
  • Pros
  • Video

  • 0.012 ounce
  • Wide shade range

  • Easy to apply
  • Works well with all skin types
  • Spoolie brush included on the end of applicator

YouTube video

Check Price on Amazon

Buyer’s Guide

Now that you’ve had the chance to look over our three favorite eyebrow pencils, it’s time to pick your favorite. Regardless of what product you decide to add to your collection, you can rest assured it will meet all of these must-have features and functions. Check out the qualities below to see if your favorite product above makes your final cut.

What makes an eyebrow pencil outstanding?

Wear time– Your eyebrows need to last all day regardless of what you do during the day. Finding a product that stays on and doesn’t budge is key to a successful eye makeup look, regardless of how you wear it. All three of these eyebrow pencils are made with long-lasting formulas, so you can wear them in confidence knowing your look will last.

Smudge-proof– Moving your face throughout the day, in bad products, almost always leads to smudged eyebrows and faded highlights. Finding a reliable and durable eyebrow pencil that doesn’t smudge or budge will save your day, every day. The products we’ve picked for you today were all designed to stay in place- so just like they won’t wear off, they won’t smudge off either.

Formula– One of the main reasons people avoid makeup, in general, is because of the formula. If you have even a slight problem with watery eyes or sensitive skin, a runny formula or drying formula could mean smears and rough patches around your eyes for days. Check for details about your favorite product that includes “sensitive skin” and “run free” to find a sensitive skin-friendly product.

Note: products with non-toxic formulas and natural ingredients are typically the best for sensitive skin unless you are allergic to a common and naturally occurring ingredient. If you experience frequent irritation with makeup products, try consulting a dermatologist to see if there are any formula types you should be avoiding! Beauty always works best when it’s safe.

Precision– Almost everybody who uses eyeliner or eyebrow products wants them to be precise. All three of the products listed above have fine pointed tips allowing for the neatest and sharpest of lines to be drawn. With any one of these three products you are guaranteed sharp points and smooth lines that can be built up if you please.

Eyebrow Pencil FAQs

What is the best way to apply eyebrow makeup?

If the product is a pencil, try to outline your brow shape (or desired brow shape, if reachable) before filling it in with hairlike strokes. After you have filled in your brow, use the pencil to touch up any areas you feel need extra love. If you have a spoolie brush, use it at the end to blur your strokes together evenly.

How do I make an eyebrow arch?

To make a sharp but natural-looking arch, start by drawing what you want the bottom of your brow to look like. Then, before adding the top lines, start filling in from the bottom at your desired angle. Once you have achieved the level of arch you want, outline the tops of your brows and smooth out as needed.

What’s a good way to remove eyebrow makeup?

Many people find micellar water or coconut oil to remove eye makeup perfectly. If neither of those are your cup of tea, try an oil-free eye makeup remover and a cotton pad. Remember, you still need to cleanse your face after removing makeup!

BC Editorial Team


{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}