Posted in Health
Last updated 12/03/2011 at 12:21 p.m. PST

'Tis the Season for Toxic Mushrooms

After fall rains, death caps are growing in abundance in Bay Area

  • Text Size
  • A
  • A
  • A
By on December 3, 2011 - 12:20 p.m. PST

You don’t have to wander very far off the road this time of year before stumbling upon Amanita phalloides, the deadliest mushroom in California.

On a recent foray in Roy’s Redwoods Open Space Preserve in Marin County, David Campbell, who has been hunting mushrooms in the county for 40 years, immediately spotted specimens of that toxic fungus, more commonly known as the death cap, growing near an entrance to the preserve.

Local conditions are ripe for fungus feasting gone wrong, according to Campbell, who has helped the San Francisco division of the California Poison Control System identify mushrooms when a poisoning has been suspected.

The death cap, which is native to Europe, has been flourishing in the Bay Area, in a symbiotic relationship with local oak trees.

This year, after the fall rains, the mushrooms are “out in large numbers, and early,” said J.R. Blair, a lecturer in the biology department at San Francisco State University.

The most serious illnesses occur when fungus enthusiasts pick and eat death cap or other poisonous mushrooms.

According to Campbell, “The chance of us having an incident any day now is very high, because people who wouldn’t normally notice mushrooms are seeing them.”

“Plenty of people have this mushroom in their backyard,” he said.

From 2009 to 2010, 271 people in the Bay Area required treatment at a health care facility after ingesting a mushroom, according to the California Poison Control System. Among them were 136 children age 5 or younger.

“We’ve never had a case of serious poisoning from an accidental mushroom poisoning where a child ate something in the backyard,” said Dr. Kent Olson, medical director of the San Francisco division of the California Poison Control System. “It’s really people preparing the mushroom thinking that it was edible.”

Statewide, two people died and 10 others suffered a major health problem, like kidney or liver failure, after eating wild mushrooms from 2009 to 2010, according to the most recent data. The deaths and the most serious illnesses have been linked to Amanita phalloides and its cousin Amanita ocreata, better known as the destroying angel. Both cause liver damage.

Related

While the two species are equally deadly, Amanita phalloides is more frequently collected and eaten, experts say.

The death cap is often a dull green color, but it can be tinged with brown or gray, or even be white. It is also reputed to be delicious. “One guy that died said it was the best mushroom he’d ever eaten,” Olson said.

State health officials advise against picking and eating wild mushrooms unless a mushroom expert evaluates the spoils first.

“It is very difficult to distinguish which mushrooms are dangerous and which are safe to eat,” Dr. Ron Chapman, director of the California Department of Public Health, said in a recent statement warning about the hazards of consuming the wrong fungus.

Health officials suggest consulting a local mycological society, like the Mycological Society of San Francisco, which is hosting its 42nd annual Fungus Fair this weekend at Lawrence Hall of Science in Berkeley.

Amanita phalloides was introduced on the West Coast in California, according to Anne Pringle, associate professor of organismic and evolutionary biology at Harvard University, who has studied the fungus’ DNA to determine its origin.

The earliest confirmed collection of the species on the West Coast was in Monterey County in the 1930s on the grounds of what was then the Del Monte Hotel, a venue famous for its gardens full of exotic species.

In 1945, the mushroom was gathered on the campus of the University of California, Berkeley, as well. Since then, it has spread, coming to thrive in the oak woodlands and mixed evergreen forests around San Francisco Bay and San Pablo Bay.

The death caps found in California are much larger than the same species back in Europe. “They’re massive,” Pringle said.

“In California, they’re also found more abundantly than in Europe,” she added.

William Freedman, chairman of the toxicology committee for the Mycology Society of San Francisco, has experienced this bounty. “In many places where I go looking for mushrooms this time of year,” he said, “they are the most common to be found.”

This article also appears in the Bay Area edition of The New York Times.

Katharine Mieszkowski
I'm a senior reporter for The Bay Citizen, covering the environment and health. I welcome your tips and comments. I've been a journalist in the Bay Area for more than 15 years, where I've been ... View Profile
M L
M L
wrote on 12/03/2011 at 6:56 p.m. PST

Who's the old friend in tow with the white muzzle and focused gaze? I love my Bay Area people with their dog co-pilots.

And very dear friend lost her Boston Terrier to on of those nasty mushrooms. So dog owners beware as well.

d g
d g
wrote on 12/04/2011 at 8:44 a.m. PST

I lost my 6 month old Bernese Mt. Dog pup last year to a Death Cap. Since then I've made it his legacy and my mission to help spread the word about mushroom toxicity. Dog owners....especially puppy owners need to beware. I've just started a blog and have posters on it that can be downloaded to warn dog owners. www.mushrooms911.blogspot.com

Katharine Mieszkowski
Katharine Mieszkowski
wrote on 12/07/2011 at 9:11 a.m. PST

Langdon Stevenson, a reader from Mill Valley, asked me to post this email he sent to me:

I read your excellent article on the Death Cap mushroom in the "NY Times" with great interest. Your story lets readers know about a serious danger to humans.. There is another peril concerning Amanitas. That is the risk posed to domestic animals particularly dogs. Three years ago we lost a wonderful labradoodle puppy to a small Amanita which he found in our garden.Ollie was under three months old when he ate the mushroom. He became ill in minutes and had a terrible seizure. We rushed him to the pet emergency hospital in San Rafael. They could not save him. Our hearts were broken. We had no idea there were poisonous Amanita mushrooms on our property.

Now we have another labradoodle. We scour our land and take no chances with any mushroom destroying them on sight. So far so good. We think we can identify the Death Caps, but we don't take a chances. Every fungus goes.

Langdon Stevenson, Mill Valley

debbie  viess
debbie viess
wrote on 12/12/2011 at 5:22 p.m. PST

Nice balanced article.

Glad to see that you contacted Dr. Anne Pringle, who has been conducting research on the spread of Amanita phalloides here in California, with some surprising results. Even more details about both her research and more information on phalloides as it occurs in California, including its disturbing habitat expansion of host trees from live oak and cork oak to tan oak and pine, can be found here:

http://www.bayareamushrooms.org/mushroommonth/amanita_phalloides.html

Also, its occurrence is far broader than merely the Bay Area sites listed. Amanita phalloides now occurs everywhere in California that there is live oak, including the Channel Islands!

I have only a few other things to add. A small correction is the quote from Kent Olson about a recent victim of a fatal amanita poisoning, that Amanita phalloides "was the best mushroom he’d ever eaten" actually was in reference to the other, native deadly California amanita, Amanita ocreata. I actually ran into the poor man's Granddaughter at a party that same spring. Very sad, and a bizarre happen-stance for an amanitologist!

Unfortunately, eaters of Amanita phalloides also claim that it is a delicious mushroom.

More importantly, a potential life and liver-saving treatment for amatoxin poisoning is now available, free to qualifying physicians and hospitals, through ongoing FDA clinical trials. Read all about IV silibinin and its use in treating serious amatoxin poisonings here:

http://www.bayareamushrooms.org/poisonings/index.html

Glad to see that the pet people also spoke up. I field a lot of calls from veterinarians and concerned pet owners, one just last night. Happy ending there, thank heavens. But education is the key to preventing serious and even deadly poisonings, and good articles like this one help a lot.

Debbie Viess
Bay Area Mycological Society
www.bayareamushrooms.org

Related Content