Posted in Health
Last updated 12/01/2010 at 4:11 p.m. PST

IRS Looking into Planned Parenthood Golden Gate After Complaint

Local clinics stripped of national affiliation as of Friday

  • Text Size
  • A
  • A
  • A
By on September 2, 2010 - 9:00 p.m. PDT
Adithya Sambamurthy/The Bay Citizen
The clinic in this building on Eddy Street in San Francisco is now operated by Golden Gate Community Health

The criminal division of the Internal Revenue Service is looking into the finances of Planned Parenthood Golden Gate, while the organization has brought in forensic accountants to evaluate its books.

The local nonprofit became Golden Gate Community Health on Friday, as the national Planned Parenthood organization stripped the Bay Area clinics of their affiliation, citing financial and administrative problems.

“It’s exactly the same entity with just a different name,” said Therese Wilson, interim chief executive of the new organization.

It will continue to operate its seven clinics in five Bay Area counties. Neighboring Planned Parenthood affiliates are scrambling to open new clinics in the same counties.

Agents for the criminal division of the I.R.S. interviewed a former employee of Planned Parenthood Golden Gate on Tuesday at the Oakland field office, in response to a complaint he had lodged.

That informant, who declined to be named for fear of how it might affect his future job prospects, said he raised concerns about the financial relationship between the organization and its political arm, as well as about accounting practices.

Jennifer Fong, a special agent for the I.R.S., declined to comment on whether an investigation was under way. “We don’t give specific details as to what we do to evaluate or investigate information we receive,” Fong said.

Wilson, who became interim chief executive of Planned Parenthood Golden Gate in January, said the I.R.S.’s criminal division had not contacted her. She said that in March she brought in a forensic accounting firm to evaluate the organization’s books for fiscal impropriety and malfeasance.

“There’s been no evidence to date of any of that,” she said, although she acknowledged that the accountants had found “inaccurate information.”

So far, the forensic accountants’ scrutiny has extended back only through the 2008-9 tax year, said Vincent Robinson, treasurer of the organization’s board.

On Wednesday at Planned Parenthood Golden Gate’s headquarters on Eddy Street in San Francisco, there was little evidence that the organization’s name was about to change.

The nonprofit will no longer run its one satellite health center, which had been offering limited services two days a week at Good Samaritan Family Resource Center in San Francisco, Wilson said.

Next Wednesday, Planned Parenthood Shasta-Diablo, an affiliate based in Concord, will begin operating a satellite health center at that location two days a week. That affiliate’s new territory will now include San Francisco, Marin, Sonoma and Mendocino Counties, said Mitzi Sales, its senior vice president for external affairs.

Planned Parenthood Mar Monte hopes to open two full-service clinics within the next year in its two new counties, San Mateo and Alameda, said Deborah Ortiz, its vice president of public affairs.

This article also appears in the Bay Area edition of The New York Times.

Correction: Due to an editing error, a previous version of this story incorrectly suggested that on a visit to Planned Parenthood Golden Gate on Wednesday, Sept. 1, the organization’s name had already changed to Golden Gate Community Health. The name changed Friday, Sept. 3.

Katharine Mieszkowski
I'm the environmental health editor for the Bay Citizen. I welcome your tips and comments, especially ideas for our Quality of Life blog: http://www.baycitizen.org/blogs/quality-of-life/ I've been a journalist in the Bay Area for more than ... View Profile
Kate McGlashan
Kate McGlashan
wrote on 09/02/2010 at 9:48 p.m. PDT

I think Therese Wilson's first move as executive director of Golden Gate Community Health should be to appoint a new spokesperson.

"It's exactly the same entity..."? Come on, lady, that entity is under investigation for criminal activity.

I think there is plenty of great corporatespeak to this purpose, such as, "We're turning the page. We're right-sizing. We're moving forward."

Or are we to assume that things will, in fact, continue as before?

R T
R T
wrote on 09/02/2010 at 10:01 p.m. PDT

Who didn't see this coming?

Ana Castle
Ana Castle
wrote on 09/02/2010 at 10:36 p.m. PDT

What exactly is a "forensic accountant"? Sounds very CSI, like people who know how to look for criminal accounting stuff. I guess regular accountants or financial advisors, who've been working there over the years were hiding stuff? That might explain why the former CEO has totally disappeared. Maybe she had people hiding her illegal or unethical financial dealings.

Darren Smith
Darren Smith
wrote on 09/03/2010 at 10:18 a.m. PDT

There are plenty of other Planned Parenthood centers which the IRS should take a long and hard look at, in my opinion. After all Planned Parenthood has received billions in tax dollars and according to a Washington Post article I read- they seem to be "Missing Millions" of that tax money. Where is the accountability to the tax payer? This is NOT the first disaffiliation PP did to avoid trouble- look at the clinics in Broward and Palm Beach Counties which had troubles- look at the whistle blower who came forward in California to state PP was overbilling Medicaid, look at NJ's clinics and their billing troubles as well as the reports from Texas...there is a disturbing Pattern developing which the government needs to address. It is the NATIONAL OFFICE and all their affiliates which should be held accountable and investigated - after all- look at the history of Planned Parenthood it is muddied up in eugenics and the founder had KLAN connections. I suggest you watch a documentary called- Maafa21 for that history (http://www.maafa21.com) and I call on the IRS to expand it's investigation- thank you !

Andy Joe
Andy Joe
wrote on 12/01/2010 at 4:11 p.m. PST

How long has Vincent Robinson been their Board treasurer? He seems fairly new.

I'm wondering because the Board members who were on the job when the organization went off the rails bare the ultimate responsibility for the organization, including executive compensation and reviewing the annual audit.

It's worth noting that in California Directors may be held personally liable to repay damages to the corporation itself where they have breached their duty of care or loyalty to the organization.

The Directors listed on PPGG's 2008-09 990 form are:

Judy Young, Chair
Linda Davis-Jones, Vice Chair
Ameena Ahmed, Vice Chair
Shoshana Chazen, Board Member
John Creighton, Board Member
Lea Gee-tong, Board Member
Sana Hamelin, Board Member
Roger Hoag, Board Member
Jenee Johnson, Board Member
Lauren Kline, Board Member
Lasha Pierce, Board Member
Shelby Stewart, Board Member
Nancy Tompkins, Board Member
Sue Baleriote, Board Member
Katherine Valentine, Board Member
Lisa Van Dusen, Board Member
Hugh Vasquez, Board Member

Plan Parenthood Golden Gate 990 form: http://www.guidestar.org/FinDocuments//2009/946/138/2009-946138828-05fd29cd-9.pdf

Related Content