Posted in Crime
Last updated 02/18/2012 at 10:25 a.m. PST

'Unlikely Messengers' for Violence Prevention

A criminal record no longer means you can’t be a mentor

  • Text Size
  • A
  • A
  • A
By on February 18, 2012 - 10:25 a.m. PST
Courtesy Photo
Philthy Richfod

Last weekend, the Oakland rapper Philthy Rich, who is on probation for firearms possession, was arrested on charges of driving an allegedly stolen Bentley. He posted $30,000 bail.

Then he made plans to speak at an elementary school in support of nonviolence.

In a past era, youth mentors were expected to have squeaky-clean records. But Philthy Rich, whose birth name is Philip Beasley, is among a new generation of role models who are being welcomed into community outreach organizations. Their credibility with young people, these groups say, is bolstered by their experience growing up in Oakland’s high-crime neighborhoods, including run-ins with the law.

Philthy Rich has become a high-profile spokesman for local violence-prevention efforts. His arrest highlights a difference in perceptions between many police officers and leaders of nonprofit groups who are eager to reach jaded inner-city youth. Community organizers say young people can relate to rappers like Philthy Rich. The police simply consider Philthy Rich a criminal.

“One of our strategies is the use of unlikely messengers,” said Nicole Lee, executive director of the Urban Peace Movement, a violence-prevention organization.

“It’s predictable that I’m going to tell them to stop the violence,” she said. “But I haven’t lived the life that Philthy Rich has.”

In his music, Philthy Rich, 29, is boastful and blunt, borrowing from tragic memories of his youth in the Seminary in East Oakland, a neighborhood rife with guns and drugs. He grew up without his father and bounced frequently between homes. His first arrest, he said, was when he was 11, after he beat up another child and stole his bicycle. In 2007, he was arrested for selling cocaine.

In 2009, as he and his cousin were attending the memorial for a friend killed in a shooting, someone opened fire. His cousin, an aspiring police officer, was killed.

A natural self-promoter, Philthy Rich spoke of his cousin’s death and a dozen others on an episode of the Discovery Channel’s “Gang Wars.” He said he was done selling drugs, and teamed up with Lee and rappers and nonprofit groups to produce a CD called “Turf Unity.” Several months later, he was arrested for illegal firearms possession. He said he was carrying a pistol for protection.

But his criminal background did not dissuade Lee and others from entrusting Philthy Rich with their message of nonviolence. Like the rapper, young people eager for protection in Oakland’s high-crime areas find it very easy to obtain illegal guns, she said.

“Our approach is really about meeting people where they are,” Lee said.

This philosophy is shared across the city, particularly in areas with high concentrations of poverty and violence.

The City of Oakland’s street-outreach team, a group that walks the city’s crime hot spots, includes several former gang members. Some 60 to 70 percent of the young people hired by Youth Uprising, an East Oakland nonprofit group, have criminal records, said Olis Simmons, the group’s executive director.

That high proportion is “not coincidental,” Simmons said. “I go after them. Hell, somebody’s got to hire them. If you can turn them around, you turn the neighborhood around.”

Many Oakland police officers view these programs as condoning lawlessness. “It’s turned into a network of mediocre criminals,” one homicide detective said about Youth Uprising. (The officer spoke on condition of anonymity because he is not authorized to speak to the news media.)

In 2010, when Too Short, the iconic Oakland rapper, was serving as a Youth Uprising counselor, he was charged with assaulting security guards at one of his shows in Idaho. The same year, another Youth Uprising employee was charged with murder and robbery.

For his part, Philthy Rich said he owned the car he was arrested in and planned to show a judge the registration papers to prove it. But he admitted that his criminal record made him an unlikely candidate for a youth mentor.

“At first it was hard, because I didn’t want to get up there, cursing and saying stop the violence, and then get up there and rap about the violence,” Philthy Rich said about his first performance at Youth Uprising. “Now I feel comfortable doing me.”

Shoshana Walter
Shoshana is the crime and punishment reporter for The Bay Citizen. Send/call tips to swalter@baycitizen.org or 415-821-8524. Before moving to the Mission, she wrote about runaway monkeys, murders and all sorts of mayhem as a ... View Profile
George Calys
George Calys
wrote on 02/18/2012 at 12:49 p.m. PST

This approach is forward-thinking and visionary. May I also suggest bringing in Bernie Madoff to mentor youngsters in investment techniques?

"Michelle Kohlhaas"
"Michelle Kohlhaas"
wrote on 02/18/2012 at 5:38 p.m. PST

“It’s turned into a network of mediocre criminals,” one homicide detective said about Youth Uprising."

A "network of mediocre criminals" is exactly how many would describe California law enforcement.

M L
M L
wrote on 02/18/2012 at 9:30 p.m. PST

Fraternizing with criminals for aspirational but irrational, delusional and demented political optics is nothing new.

I attended a planning department meeting in San Francisco where some nasty characters were especially imported for the public comment period (they got to go 1st, and left immediately afterward rather than stick around to listen to what others thought).

The subject at hand was removing a grassy play area and replacing it with basketball courts. They freely admitted that they didn't live in or ever visit the neighborhood, but insisted the reason why they was the dearth of appropriate sporting areas for their game of choice.

Actual neighbors just looked at one another in stoic shock. Planning staff seemed very pleased with whatever point it was they think they made.

A non-profit in my neighborhood that prided itself on hiring gang members ended up in a pickle because "staff" stole everything that wasn't tied down.

Your Black Muslim Bakery and the People's Temple before it are even grander and crazier examples of this phenomenon.

Mayor Moscone appointed Jim Jones as the Chairman of the San Francisco Housing Authority Commission. His tenure was marked by hard to miss portents of worse things yet to come.

This article illustrates similar portents, but then Oakland has become on giant portal of portent: what happens when swaths of an entire city slip into a cult of death and a chorus that sings only the same one tune of sorrowful self-defeat.

Roland Salvato
Roland Salvato
wrote on 02/21/2012 at 10:35 a.m. PST

Your example of the non-locals who pitched for the basketball courts caught my attention. I hope the ruse didn't work. Is this available in Planning meeting minutes or something?
Thanks.

R T
R T
wrote on 02/21/2012 at 10:17 a.m. PST

It sounds like a great idea- have the people who can actually speak the language and from experience talk about getting out of the life, etc. It seems the execution leaves something to be desired. One thing that the article didn't cover was how many speakers/mentors has the Urban Peace Movement used? 10? 20? 30 100? Makes a big difference is we are saying that 3 out of 250 mentors have screwed up and not been perfect role models vs 3 out of 10.

Roland Salvato
Roland Salvato
wrote on 02/21/2012 at 10:37 a.m. PST

Problem with this approach is the obvious dissonance between WORDS and ACTIONS. This rapper has no role-model credibility to encourage youngsters to stop violence and crime. The end result is just entertainment and marketing.

Related Content