The Bay Citizen thanks our sponsors
The Bay Citizen thanks our sponsors
Posted in Technology

Updated 04/25/2011 at 5:43 p.m. PDT

The Promise of Rapture For the High-Tech Elite

Ray Kurzweil's notion of "the Singularity" offers an answer to existential questions, wrapped in a package of science and innovation

  • Text Size
  • A
  • A
  • A
By on April 23, 2011 - 2:00 p.m. PDT

kurzweil
Larry Larry Busacca/Getty Images
Ray Kurzweil
Ray Kurzweil, the influential technologist, came to the Palace of Fine Arts theater in San Francisco a few days ago to promote his vision of “the Singularity.” One attendee admiringly described it as “the cult Rapture of the Nerds.”

It was a much more fitting prelude to the Easter holidays than Kurzweil would like to think.

The Singularity, as he explains it, is a point in the near future when rapidly escalating technological advances will allow the most evolved humans (i.e., Kurzweil and his early-adopting followers) to incorporate technology into their bodies. Doing so will allow them to live hundreds of years and perhaps forever. Kurzweil wrote a book on the subject in 2005 and has been proselytizing ever since. The quick sell: Join me in outsmarting death.

This vision has obvious appeal to the Silicon Valley set, which holds sacred the belief that technology can solve most any problem; Google’s co-founder Larry Page, and a long list of other tech celebrities, helped establish Singularity University, where rich or deep-thinking techies try to get an edge on the future.

New Agers, too, find something alluring in the idea of man transcending the mere self and attaching to a more grandiose vision of the human project.

Yet there is a flip side to the Singularity, a distinctly unmodern religiosity of the sort that often horrifies high-powered engineers and sophisticated citizens of the New Economy. Kurzweil offers the best of both worlds, as it were: an answer to existential questions and the ageless quest for immortality, wrapped in a package of science and innovation.

Michael Lindvall, a theologian and pastor of Brick Presbyterian Church in New York, pegs Kurzweil’s Singularity dogma as a modern iteration of the Gnosticism prevalent in the second and third centuries.

Gnosticism “was basically the idea that people save themselves by being smart,” Lindvall said. “By knowing these secret things, you would become cognoscenti, one of the few, elitist. Gnostics looked down on the hoi polloi Christian masses.”

Related

Kevin Kelly, a co-founder of Wired magazine and an influential technology theorist himself, is not an adherent of the Singularity, but has spoken at length with Kurzweil about it and certainly sees the appeal.

“It attracts people who are scientific, rational, not religious,” Kelly said, “and it offers them the same comforting idea that heaven offers to someone more religious.”

Kurzweil said, via email, that any comparison of Singularity to religion was “incorrect.”

“Religions emerged in pre-scientific times” he wrote, and are “based on faith and not science.”

“We need to update our understanding of the destiny of our human-machine civilization based on what science now tells us,” he added. “The bottom line is that my thesis is based on a detailed scientific analysis of the history of technology and not on faith.”

Certainly, some of Kurzweil’s adherents seemed overcome with religious fervor at his recent San Francisco appearance. “His fans notoriously swarm the stage, like they are doing here!” an event organizer barked at other staff members during a VIP reception, warning them to be alert.

Kurzweil predicts the Singularity will occur in about 2040. Kelly suggests he so tirelessly promotes it in hopes of speeding things along. In 2040, Kurzweil would be 92. He obsesses over his diet and consumes 150 pills a day to stave off aging.

Thoughts of mortality produce “profoundly sad and lonely feelings,” Kurzweil said in “Transcendent Man,” a filmed accompaniment to his live presentation. “So I go back to thinking about how I’m not going to die.” (The German words “kurz weil,” by the way, translate into “short time,” so perhaps Kurzweil was predestined to obsess over ways to extend his life.)

Ken Marks, a local mathematician, was one of 700 or so who came to hear Kurzweil — and he was skeptical about the whole thing. His objections were scientific, rather than theological, saying that the Singularity ignored the scientific principle of complementary pairs. Like space and time, or electric force and magnetic force, “death and life are a complementary pair,” Marks said. “Death is intrinsic to life.”

“If you do not have death, you do not have life,” he said.

Kelly suggests such scientific nitpicking wouldn’t hold much sway with Kurzweil, though he, too, is a man of science.

“The remarkable thing about Ray is that he has no doubt,” Kelly said. “He has an answer for every objection. His certainty is unwavering.”

Is that faith, in the traditional sense? “Exactly,” Kelly said. “He has faith.”

This article also appears in the Bay Area edition of The New York Times.

Elizabeth Lesly Stevens
Senior writer Elizabeth Lesly Stevens writes primarily about business and finance. A recent transplant to San Francisco, she spent many years in New York as an editor and writer at Business Week, a media-business columnist ... View Profile
More Column Posts

Local Novelist Fights Hollywood, and Faces Long Odds

In 1998, Joe Quirk, a Bay Area novelist, wrote “Ultimate Rush,” a thriller about an adrenaline-fueled messenger who tears through ......
By Elizabeth Lesly Stevens    8/20/11 12:18 p.m. PDT

It’s Not Easy Being the Conservative One

Being the conservative outsider in the San Francisco mayoral race, the position staked out by Tony Hall, is a lonely ......
By Elizabeth Lesly Stevens    8/06/11 11:32 a.m. PDT

A Tax Policy With San Francisco Roots

Henry George, the 19th-century political economist, spent his seminal years in San Francisco. He is no longer a household name, ......
By Elizabeth Lesly Stevens    7/30/11 3:21 p.m. PDT

City's Children Vanish, and City Hall Wonders Why

For Leslie Kossoff, an artist who lived in San Francisco for nearly two decades, her decision to leave the city ......
By Elizabeth Lesly Stevens    7/23/11 10:12 a.m. PDT