Trey Bundy

Student Shot by UC Berkeley Police Dies


Getty Images/Justin Sullivan
UC Berkeley students walk by Sather Tower on the UC Berkeley campus April 17, 2007

Updated Nov. 16, 2011 at 11:41 a.m.

A UC Berkeley student who was shot by campus police Tuesday has died, campus officials said Wednesday morning.

Christopher Nathen Elliot Travis, 32, was an undergraduate at the Haas School of Business. Police say he was shot after brandishing a loaded weapon inside a computer lab at the school Tuesday afternoon. He died at Highland Hospital on Tuesday night.

The shooting occurred shortly about 2:20 p.m. Tuesday as an Occupy Cal protest was under way, but it was not clear whether the incident was related to the protest.

“There’s nothing to suggest that that is the case, but we don’t know,” University of California Police Department Chief Mitchell Celaya said at a press conference Tuesday afternoon.

At a press briefing Wednesday, UC Berkeley Chancellor Robert Birgeneau said, “It’s a very challenging time. It helps put in perspective all of the other challenges we are dealing with.”

Birgeneau said his "heart goes out to the family of this young man."

The student had transferred to Cal this semester, but campus officials would not say what school he had previously attended.

One witness had told police that the student had been acting "not normal" before the shooting, but officers would not elaborate on what that meant.

Police learned that there was a student with a weapon after a Haas staff member named Susie rode an elevator with the suspect. He looked at her, took what appeared to be a gun out of his backpack and put it back, according to Celaya.

Susie told Lyle Nevels, the business school's chief information officer, what she had seen, and the pair went into the third-floor computer lab. They saw the man, whom Nevels described as white, in his mid-20s, wearing jeans and with short, brownish-grayish hair, sitting at a computer. A gun was not visible at that time.

They called the University of California Police Department, which sent three officers to respond. When the police entered the computer lab and approached the suspect, he pulled the gun out of his backpack in a "threatening manner," Celaya said.

Alex Arroyo and Loren Fuell, Berkeley students who work at the computer lab, were sitting at a desk outside the lab at the time of the shooting. They said they heard the officers say repeatedly, "Drop the gun," before four or five shots were fired.

Just one of the officers fired the shots, Celaya said, but all three have been placed on leave, in accordance with department policy.

Kaulin Krebs, a junior at UC Berkeley, said he was arriving at the computer lab around 2:15 p.m. when he heard someone say, "Drop to the ground, a guy has a gun." He saw about 15 people on the floor of the computer lab.

According to Celaya, at least four students were between the officers and the suspect in the computer lab. Celaya said there may have been a surveillance camera in the room, but “I have not seen it and there are questions if it was functioning at the time.”

No one besides the suspect was injured. Students and faculty were evacuated from the building, and allowed back in after 4 p.m. to retrieve their belongings.

The UCPD is the lead agency in the investigation and has interviewed 17 witnesses in addition to the officers involved in the shooting. Police have recovered a weapon, according to UCPD Capt. Margo Bennett.

The last shooting at Cal took place in the 1980s in the Bear's Lair, a bar on campus.

The Bay City News Service contributed to this report.

Trey Bundy
Trey Bundy writes about youth for The Bay Citizen. He worked for 10 years as a residential treatment counselor with children from backgrounds of abuse and neglect. In 2009, he won the national William Randolph ... View Profile
"Michelle Kohlhaas"
"Michelle Kohlhaas"
wrote on 11/16/2011 at 12:03 p.m. PST

Mr. Bundy:

It appears from this report that a student was killed by police, but that there are no non-police witnesses who saw him brandish the gun in the computer lab where he was gunned down.

Was there an actual gun that was recovered? I see references in this report to "no gun was visible" at the location where he was shot and "what looked like a gun" in the elevator. But where is:

1) confirmation that student had weapon and brandished it against anyone else
2) confirmation of recovery of said "gun"
3) surveillance tape (and if it is missing, WHY?)

Thanks for any answers, Mr. Bundy.

Trey Bundy
Trey Bundy
wrote on 11/17/2011 at 9:43 a.m. PST

Thanks for your comment, Michelle. Please see the update here:

http://www.baycitizen.org/crime/story/police-man-fatally-shot-uc-berkeley-was/

It addresses some of your questions.

R T
R T
wrote on 11/16/2011 at 12:42 p.m. PST

Wow "Michelle" seeing as the shooting happened less than 24 hours ago and the Cal police are also dealing with quite a few protestors as well, it seems to me quite a bit of information has already been released. I would slow your roll for a bit and let the cops do their job and the information will be released.

"Michelle Kohlhaas"
"Michelle Kohlhaas"
wrote on 11/16/2011 at 1:17 p.m. PST

I understand the timeline, but the notion that the police are capable of effectively investigating their own deadly action is as woefully naive as believing Goldman Sachs can regulate itself.

When the police or anyone else is involved in a fatal shooting, it is (duh) rational to ask questions. When the police are investigating their own use of force, it is rational to be skeptical.

R T
R T
wrote on 11/16/2011 at 2:31 p.m. PST

It is pretty standard for the agency that did the shooting to also be the lead agency. In addition the District Attorney also conducts an investigation. For Example- SFPD does a shooting, they do not call in OPD or any other agency to conduct the investigation- they conduct it themselves- with oversight from the DA's office. Duh. Also- a closer read of the article shows that there is not a mention of the "tape" missing- it is a question of whether or not it was functioning at the time. Huge difference. I am seeing that you choose to see what you want. The article mentioned that the gun was not visible when the school staff went back into the computer lab. You seem to take this to the level that the gun was not present at the time of the shooting. Give it a break.

"Michelle Kohlhaas"
"Michelle Kohlhaas"
wrote on 11/16/2011 at 3:08 p.m. PST

"Give it a break"???
Hey, why not give the taxpayer a break and can Ricardo Guerrero, the SF cop who "earned" $683,000 in three years wages off the taxpayer and yet was busted for stealing from the poor at SRO hotels?
Why not give the taxpayer a break and pay SFPD officers not a penny more than ER residents at UCSF?
Why not give the taxpayer a break and NOT pay starting salaries of $82,000 to SFPD?

R T
R T
wrote on 11/16/2011 at 3:17 p.m. PST

What in the world does SFPD and some SFPD cop have to do with this?

"Michelle Kohlhaas"
"Michelle Kohlhaas"
wrote on 11/16/2011 at 4:02 p.m. PST

Good question for yourself, since you brought up SFPD practices.

BTW, given your unquestioning fealty to the police of all stripes, wouldn't you feel more at home in Beijing?

"Michelle Kohlhaas"
"Michelle Kohlhaas"
wrote on 11/16/2011 at 3:00 p.m. PST

"Example- SFPD does a shooting, they do not call in OPD or any other agency to conduct the investigation- they conduct it themselves- with oversight from the DA's office."

And that's been part of the problem. It's also why public confidence in the wildly overpaid and disastrously undisciplined SFPD is so low.

BTW, are you paid by the POA and/or related police unions and lobbyists to defend them against any citizen who asks entirely rational questions about overuse of force and police incompetence? If so, I hope you earn a good rate for such meretricious services.

R T
R T
wrote on 11/16/2011 at 3:19 p.m. PST

Jumping to conclusions again I see "Michelle". You are jumping right to the conclusion that this was an overuse of force and that the cops were incompetent. I am saying the same thing I say every time there is a police shooting and people like you start the screaming. Give it time and let everyone do their job. If it was a bad shoot- i.e. Oscar grant- it will come out and be dealt with.

"Michelle Kohlhaas"
"Michelle Kohlhaas"
wrote on 11/16/2011 at 4:08 p.m. PST

Wow, I've got a cache of records on SFPD that says you're historically wrong.

Bad shoots aren't "dealt with" at SFPD - they're ignored or glossed over.

That's not to say that all or even the majority of SFPD officers are unethical incompetent or violent.

But excusing all police behavior, and claiming that problems are properly "dealt with" is belied by the ongoing FBI investigation of SFPD.

And if I were a POA hack, as you may well be, I'd rethink the strategy. All you've achieved in this thread is opening up multiple PR vulnerabilities of SFPD.

The officers deserve a better hack than yourself.

R T
R T
wrote on 11/17/2011 at 8:29 a.m. PST

"Michelle", you have obviously had a bad experience or two with SFPD. Sorry that happened and have a good life.

Add a Comment

Join the Conversation

Not a member yet? Register Now

You must sign in to post a comment.

or