Trey Bundy

Defense Lawyers Decry Plan to Put Marin Juvenile Suspects in a Glass Box


Plans for Glass Cage in Marin Juvenile Courtroom
Plans for a glass enclosure in Marin County's only juvenile courtroom
As a debate heats up over whether juvenile suspects in Marin County should be required to sit inside a glass enclosure during court proceedings, 19 local defense attorneys issued a letter to judges Friday opposing the plan.

The authors wrote that the proposal — intended as a security measure — would send a message that all juvenile suspects are “too violent or dangerous to be afforded the same dignity and respect as that afforded to adults on trial for committing alleged acts of murder, mayhem or child molestation.”

The plan would require minors to appear before judges from inside a glass box about 8 feet tall, regardless of whether they are suspected of committing violent offenses.

Kim Turner, Marin’s executive court officer, defended the plan earlier this week, citing budget issues that have decreased the availability of bailiffs and an increase in cases involving serious offenses.

Friday’s letter cited past court cases that the defense attorneys said proved the new plan would violate the civil liberties of minors.

Confining kids in a glass contraption, they wrote, would be an “affront to the dignity and decorum of judicial proceedings” and would breed “disrespect for the entire judicial system.”

Trey Bundy
Trey Bundy writes about youth for The Bay Citizen. He worked for 10 years as a residential treatment counselor with children from backgrounds of abuse and neglect. In 2009, he won the national William Randolph ... View Profile
Charles Jencks
Charles Jencks
wrote on 07/15/2011 at 7:44 p.m. PDT

Right, Marin one of the wealthiest places in the world can't afford what thousands of cities across the US provide as a matter of course. This is so wrong it strains belief. Clearly someone in authority can't be bothered to review who they have in custody & take appropriate measures. Perhaps racism plays a role too.

william  petrocelli
william petrocelli
wrote on 07/16/2011 at 5:53 p.m. PDT

This is a truly bad, ill-considered idea.

Has anyone thought what happens to the defense attorneys?

If they are forced to sit outside of the box, then they can't confer properly with their clients and give them any proper representation. The fairness of the trial would be severely compromised.

If they are forced to sit inside the box, then they could be the victims of any violence by the client and no one would be able to to help them.

This idea should be scrapped for that reason alone.

Add a Comment

Join the Conversation

Not a member yet? Register Now

You must sign in to post a comment.

or